The Richard Malmgren Collection of Hawaii
Lot 17

Hawaii, 1862 Boston, Mass. to Honolulu, Sandwich Islands,
oversized cover franked with U.S. 1861, 90¢ blue (72) deep rich color and wide margins, tied by black "Paid" in oval, with red "Boston, Ms., Oct 28" cds alongside, addressed to "Hon. Elisha H. Allen, Honolulu, Sandwich Islands" with "Via San Francisco" manuscript directive at upper left, and "For Mrs. Allen" at lower left, Very Fine, ex-Adm. Harris, Meyers & Grassi; with 1980 & 2004 P.F. certificates.
Estimate $30,000 - 40,000.
ONLY RECORDED USE OF US 90¢ 1861 ISSUE ON COVER TO HAWAII AND ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT COVERS OF THE ENTIRE 1861 ISSUE
Elisha Allen was the Chief Justice of the Hawaiian Supreme Court at the time this was mailed, either in 1861 or 1862. Since the 90¢ stamp was not issued until August of 1861, it is likely an 1862 usage. The cover would have been sent overland by rail to St. Louis, Missouri and then put on the Butterfield stage route to San Francisco via El Paso and Los Angeles. For an 1861 usage, this cover would have likely made the Nov. 24 sailing of the clipper ship "Carrington" assuming a 27-day transit time from Boston to San Francisco, arriving in Honolulu on Dec. 19. For a more likely 1862 usage, a 26-day rail/stage transit time to S.F. would have enabled a Nov. 22 departure sailing from San Francisco on the barque "Young Hector", which arrived in Honolulu Dec. 8, 1862 with a month's accumulation of both Eastern and California mails. This cover is prepaid at nine-times the 10¢ rate per ½ ounce for a letter weighing between 4 and 4½ ounces. It was the subject of analysis by Richard B. Graham in P.F. Opinions, 1983. According to Graham, the use of a 90¢ stamp on a relatively small envelope indicates that the content must have been a small pamphlet or daguerreotype.