The Richard Malmgren Collection of Hawaii
Lot 68

Hawaii, (Oahu) Honolulu, Hawaiian Is., Apr. 30, 1851,
remarkably clear full strike of the Honolulu straightline cancel struck in black ink, on a folded letter to "Royal C. Knapp Esq., care of Messrs Wm. Fell & Co, Merchants, San Francisco, A. California", manuscript directive at top left "per John Calvin", red "San Francisco, May 22" cds with matching clamshell "Ship 6" marking for port-of-entry delivery; some light wear and a some age spotting, Very Fine, Gregory census no. 26, ex-Pietsch.
Estimate $7,500 - 10,000.
ONE OF TWO RECORDED HONOLULU STRAIGHTLINE COVERS TO SAN FRANCISCO, RECEIVING ITS PORT-OF-ENTRY CLAMSHELL 6 MARKING
Of the 26 surviving examples of the Honolulu straightline postmark in black ink, only 3 are dated April 30, 1851. William Fell & Co., the designated 'care/of' addressee, was founded by a Danish immigrant who arrived in San Francisco in 1849 during the Gold Rush craze. He became a prominent figure in the City's early days of infrastructure development, involved with street paving and establishing the Fire Dept. He founded the Fireman's Fund Insurance Co. in 1863. While the sender's directive indicated carriage by the John Calvin, this letter was likely sent out a day earlier on the British bark Thetis (dep. Honolulu Apr. 29; arr. SF May 22) since the John Calvin did not arrive in SF until May 24. Thus, it would appear that Henry Whitney had pre-set the postmark device for a scheduled April 30 departure of the John Calvin, but then was given the opportunity to send the mail out a day earlier on the Thetis.