The Westpex Auction
Lot 593
No featured image available
James Stuart Hung by the Vigilance Committee on Market Street Wharf, on the 11th of July 1851
(Baird 121), published and lithographed by Justh, Quirot & Co. of a "View Taken from the Storeship Byron" on July 11, 1851 at the end of the Market Street Wharf looking back toward the city, the crowd, as with Jenkins, grabbed the rope with a will and Stuart hangs on a cargo crane between the masts of the brig in the left foreground, image on gray paper on an 11.25x17.85" folded double sheet, with lengthy letter written by Panken Brown "San Francisco, July 18, 1851" to his daughter Susan M. Brown…I thought I would purchase this sheet of the drawing, or painting of the execution of James Stewart, who was executed on Market St. Wharf within about 20 feet of the bows of the Byron [a bark that arrived on July 12, 1850, 127 days from Bangor, Maine]. You will see the Brig Maquila [?] lying at the lower end of the wharf, her stern against the Byron's side, which end the Byron's bough lay against the wharf, and the view was taken from the Byron's deck, so that you can only see the stern of the Byron…This was the doings of the Vigilance Committee that are doing great good in this city, and through out this state, and the papers give the good tidings that three are to be executed tomorrow at Sacramento City, and there are 2 or 3 that will meet the same fate in a few days here…Market St. wharf is about 200 yards long, and 20 wide, and you will see the wharf was crowded, and the water was covered with Boats, and the Byron's and brig's deck, and every thing in perfect order and stillness. The Vigilent committee, about 500 came from their rooms, four deep, each man with a pare of revolvers and Dirk, and Stewart in front and then hung on the crain that is used to hoist in Cargo with; minor wear, Very Fine.
Estimate $2,000 - 3,000.
A REMARKABLE LETTER AND LETTERSHEET DEPICTING AND DISCUSSING THE HANGING OF JAMES STUART
On February 19, 1851, James Stuart, a former Australian convict, 49er, and leader of a gang of robbers in the mines and cities, clubbed dry goods merchant Charles Jansen and stole $2000. This was the first robbery of a member of the commercial elite, incensing San Francisco. Casually arrested on July 2 for a suspected robbery, boatman John Sullivan, who had captured Jenkins, recognized the prisoner as "English Jim." The scene is based on a watercolor by English artist John Prendergast titled, "Justice Meted Out to English Jim." (Jeanne Van Nostrand and Edith M. Coulter, California Pictorial (1948), 150-1.) A week after the hanging, our letter-writer Panken Brown makes reference to the "painting;" he implies both were on the deck of the bark Byron.